Halan
Global Moderator 
Purple Haze
A good assassin needs neither the dark or the light....he needs skill (Was Mandalore)
Posts: 11,843
|
Post by Halan on May 20, 2005 21:24:14 GMT
Most are good... The weezing and coughing fucks them up a little. I didnt like they way he bowed to Lord Sidious. What is wrong with him bowing to his bosses boss? |
|
Jetzt
Administrator 
Dave & Rupert
Posts: 11,771
|
Post by Jetzt on May 20, 2005 21:37:20 GMT
It was too stiff... too unreal. It was an "over the top" bow.
|
|
Enishi
Full Member
He alone is my rock, and my salvation; he is my fortress I will not be Shaken...
Posts: 2,255
|
Post by Enishi on May 20, 2005 22:16:20 GMT
I loved the movie. Some things were out of place, but good. So much emotion, but how can strangling somone for a few minutes cause them to die in child birth? And Jet Lucas was the kid who helped Bail Organa out of being shot, right? Also, the actor who played Ayla Secura, said she wouldn't die. She was shot a million times even when she fell!
*EDIT*
And to answer General Grievous's coughing, Mace Windu had used a type of force crush on his exo-ribs. Watch the Clone Wars Volume II (cartoon by Genndy Tartatofsky.)
|
|
|
|
Post by darthheritious on May 21, 2005 0:05:12 GMT
I tell you what killed the entire fucking movie for me........Qui-Gon Jinn! Why wasnt Qui-Gon Jinn shown in the fucking movie as a ghost or something? Yeah Yeah people can say "Liam Neeson was unavailable for a cameo" but fuck that! Lucas should have had Liam under contract to make one last appearence as Qui-Gon in this movie! He could have popped up next to Obi-Wan as he dropped off Luke to Owen and Beru on Tattooine but that was too much to fucking ask! Yoda only mentioning to Obi-wan that Qui-Gon would further his training is not enough. I hope to God the DVD when it comes out has that in there as a deleted scene or part of an extended edition otherwise this movie will always be missing a key bridge between the OT and the PT IMO!
|
|
Adena
Administrator
retired from RP'ing GODDESS
BOO!
Posts: 6,705
|
Post by Adena on May 21, 2005 0:11:27 GMT
I saw quigons ghost in the company cut of it that I saw..I've not seen the public release yet so... But sence it WAS there in the uncut version I'd assume the DVD will have it
oh and Jetzt,, LOVE the sig * wink
|
|
|
|
Post by darthheritious on May 21, 2005 0:12:48 GMT
I saw quigons ghost in the company cut of it that I saw..I've not seen the public release yet so... But sence it WAS there in the uncut version I'd assume the DVD will have it oh and Jetzt,, LOVE the sig * wink Can you tell me what that scene you saw was like? Did he talk or what? |
|
Adena
Administrator
retired from RP'ing GODDESS
BOO!
Posts: 6,705
|
Post by Adena on May 21, 2005 0:21:07 GMT
Can you tell me what that scene you saw was like? Did he talk or what? It was exactly where you said it should have been...Though he didn't talk, looks like they used some screen tests from EP1 and made it ghosty, or did a CG replica, but he simply folded his arms inside his sleeves and nodded....still cheap in my view, but it was him and that made it better |
|
|
|
Post by Lady Zahra/Jules on May 21, 2005 0:52:18 GMT
My two BIGGEST problems with the movie was that they didn't show more of the fights with the clones being led by the Jedi on other worlds as well as the fight on Kashyyk. I expected to see a whole lot more there.
Also, the Jedi were cut down waaaay too easily after Code 66. Plus, what planets were they on? Not everyone had seen The Clone Wars and could figure it out. I kept having problems trying to figure out what planets they were on.
For Grevious. I didn't like his character. His part was way over before he was killed. Also, where did he come from? How did he come to be? If they are going to give him that much screen time, they should have done more.
What I loved: I absolutely loved the relationship between Anakin and Obi-wan. It was great to see it all play out. Also, to see the struggle Anakin really had.....he didn't fall easily...he really did have a hard time. I loved the way Palpy manipulated him and got what he wanted the whole way. Everything he did worked out perfectly. As for Mace, he's always sooo hard to read. I don't like him that much because of that...lol. The fight scenes were awesome. Palpy rocks with a saber! I just loved this movie!!! You can't help but feel for Anakin and all he goes through.
|
|
Jetzt
Administrator
Dave & Rupert
Posts: 11,771
|
Post by Jetzt on May 21, 2005 1:14:32 GMT
Tellanroaeg, Saleucami, Mygeeto and Cato Nemoidia
Grievous was a Kaleesh Worrior... Sidious and Dooku wanted him to join with the sith but he refused...
Sidious was not happy and decided to fuck him up. All that survived was his nerves, brain, eyes and other organs. He was trained by Dooku but was not a sith.
|
|
|
|
Post by Lady Zahra/Jules on May 21, 2005 1:29:57 GMT
whoa! Thanks, Jetzt!
|
|
Enishi
Full Member
He alone is my rock, and my salvation; he is my fortress I will not be Shaken...
Posts: 2,255
|
Post by Enishi on May 21, 2005 1:36:54 GMT
2 questions.
1: Where did you find out about grievous being a kaleesh warrior?
2: Mind showin a pic of a Kaleesh warrior?
|
|
|
|
Post by lightbringer on May 21, 2005 2:48:08 GMT
I have seen it three times now! I have to say some of things I have picked up...
Best lightsaber move that has ever been witnessed was the way Anakin cuts of Dooku's hands...simply a badass move the way he angled his saber around Dooku's.
GG fight vs Obi-Wan was weird and ya cant even tell whats going on. It doesnt really show Obi blocking all the lightsaber attacks, and how he cut of his hands is really a mystery..
The paper rock scissors theory is blown to hell in this movie.
Yoda is stronger than Mace but Mace defeats Sidious, but it meant to be? He must have felt Anakin had arrived if he could sense him all the way on Mustafar. Obi beats Anakin but thats not the thing...Anakin is far stronger than Obi-wan was and it tells this in the prequel novels, so how does he fight Anakin for so long and so well when Dooku owned Obi-Wan like a little b!tch...then Anakin owns Dooku super quick. This made no sense. ya have to see it for yourself. Dooku straight up b!tch slapped Obi and Anakin is 10 times stronger than Dooku.
Sidious was wearing a mask to lok normal. his face changes drasticaly after the Windu battle.
One of the greatest scenes ever was when Sidious was talking to Anakin after killing Mace. His voice was hella scarey as was his eyes. I still hear that voice in my head now...creepy!
Also a tid bit about GG...He was implanted with a chip in his brain to make him very hate filled and pissed off all the time. It wasn't like that before.
GG History: He was a great leader and general of his people. His planet was attacked by an insectoid race on the planet next to his...GG race kicked some bug ass all the way back their planet and then invade the insect world. The insects went to the republic and asked for aid against the reptilian warriors. The republic and the jedi came and squashed GGs attack against them and he has hated the republic and the jedi ever since. GG believed that the republic aided the insects because they so much resources to aid the republic so they sided with them. The banking clan visited GG on his home planet and asked that he lead thier armies in the clone wars in return for financial aid from the sepratists, and he eagerly accepted...he wasnt what Sidious had planned in a lot of ways so they made his shuttle crash...he awoke in a metallic prison with a chip in his brain that made him filled with hate and anger.
|
|
|
|
Post by darthheritious on May 21, 2005 3:47:10 GMT
I have seen it three times now! I have to say some of things I have picked up... Best lightsaber move that has ever been witnessed was the way Anakin cuts of Dooku's hands...simply a badass move the way he angled his saber around Dooku's. GG fight vs Obi-Wan was weird and ya cant even tell whats going on. It doesnt really show Obi blocking all the lightsaber attacks, and how he cut of his hands is really a mystery.. The paper rock scissors theory is blown to hell in this movie. Yoda is stronger than Mace but Mace defeats Sidious, but it meant to be? He must have felt Anakin had arrived if he could sense him all the way on Mustafar. Obi beats Anakin but thats not the thing...Anakin is far stronger than Obi-wan was and it tells this in the prequel novels, so how does he fight Anakin for so long and so well when Dooku owned Obi-Wan like a little b!tch...then Anakin owns Dooku super quick. This made no sense. ya have to see it for yourself. Dooku straight up b!tch slapped Obi and Anakin is 10 times stronger than Dooku. Sidious was wearing a mask to lok normal. his face changes drasticaly after the Windu battle. One of the greatest scenes ever was when Sidious was talking to Anakin after killing Mace. His voice was hella scarey as was his eyes. I still hear that voice in my head now...creepy! Also a tid bit about GG...He was implanted with a chip in his brain to make him very hate filled and pissed off all the time. It wasn't like that before. GG History: He was a great leader and general of his people. His planet was attacked by an insectoid race on the planet next to his...GG race kicked some bug ass all the way back their planet and then invade the insect world. The insects went to the republic and asked for aid against the reptilian warriors. The republic and the jedi came and squashed GGs attack against them and he has hated the republic and the jedi ever since. GG believed that the republic aided the insects because they so much resources to aid the republic so they sided with them. The banking clan visited GG on his home planet and asked that he lead thier armies in the clone wars in return for financial aid from the sepratists, and he eagerly accepted...he wasnt what Sidious had planned in a lot of ways so they made his shuttle crash...he awoke in a metallic prison with a chip in his brain that made him filled with hate and anger. Sidious wasnt wearing a mask.......He almost got his face melted off by Mace deflecting the lightning back at him with his light saber. Atleast thats how i took it. |
|
|
|
Post by darthheritious on May 21, 2005 3:56:10 GMT
Oh and one last thing about something Jetzt said..........George Lucas is a visionary film maker but the people he hires to edit his movies suck!
|
|
|
|
Post by darthheritious on May 21, 2005 4:08:28 GMT
Damn i just cant shut up about this movie lol Anyway i didnt like one scene above all the others but i did like that Padme still had the snipet carving that Anakin made her when he was little. I got goosebumps when i saw that. Small things like that make the story i think.
|
|
