Post by rcgary on May 19, 2005 8:24:36 GMT
Well, I guess I feel bad that I was disappointed ....and I really really wanted ROTS to rock. The dialogue was better I thought, but the delivery was horrible...especially Padame's lines. They seemed contrite and forced.
The Wookies... Yoda mentions that he will miss them. Doesn't that hint towards attachment which he tell Anakin earlier is the path to the dark side???
In the recording at the Jedi Temple...Palpatine tells Vader to go and restore peace to the Empire..but Palpatine hasn't delivered the Republic-to-Empire speech yet. Also, when Obi-Wan lands on Mustafar to confront Anakin, Anakin first refers to it as the Republic, then 2 lines later calls it "HIS Empire".
Did anyone else see the Falcon when Anakin and Obi-Wan's Shuttle is landing with Palpatine after his rescue?
Why mention Darth Plageous if you're not going to say who his apprententice was (If you read the book you know it was Palpatine).
The action seemed like it moved....too fast if anything. I don't wear glasses and don't need them, but the action was so fast it seemed blurred.
I thought the Obi-Wan/Grevious fight was rushed, especially with how fast Obi-Wan cut off 2 of his 4 hands. I mean, Grevious is supposed to be this all powerful Jedi killing machine (no pun intended). He has numberous lightsabers from the Jedi he killed, yet in less than 3 minutes Obi-Wan has cut his attack and defense potential in half?!?!!?!
I love Ian McDiramid, I think he has done a great job with Palpatine over the years..but his lightsaber skills SUCKED!!!
R2...man, how could Lucas make me hate R2? Dunno, but he did.
There were screen shots leaked of Qui-Gon in ghost form, yet we never see him. I believe it's even on the credits too.
Mickey Suttle...aka Supershadow. Well, I initially defended him, but I've done a lot of research since then and there are huge holes in things he said. FRAUD!!!
I half thought we'd hear Vader cry out "I am not a machine, I am a human Being!" ala the Elephant Man. The manorisms were all wrong for that scene.
It takes 18 years to complete the first Death Star..when the Incrastructure and skeleton appeared to be in place at the end of EP3..yet only 6 for DS2 to be say 60% complete and have the weapons systems operational?
How about this goof. Bail Organa goes to the senate towards the end because he is the senator from? Alderan, right? Why is he in the Naboo Senate Pod?
There's more but after seeing this tradegy twice in the span of 4 hours tonight, I am off to bed..I'm so depressed...more tomorrow.
The Wookies... Yoda mentions that he will miss them. Doesn't that hint towards attachment which he tell Anakin earlier is the path to the dark side???
In the recording at the Jedi Temple...Palpatine tells Vader to go and restore peace to the Empire..but Palpatine hasn't delivered the Republic-to-Empire speech yet. Also, when Obi-Wan lands on Mustafar to confront Anakin, Anakin first refers to it as the Republic, then 2 lines later calls it "HIS Empire".
Did anyone else see the Falcon when Anakin and Obi-Wan's Shuttle is landing with Palpatine after his rescue?
Why mention Darth Plageous if you're not going to say who his apprententice was (If you read the book you know it was Palpatine).
The action seemed like it moved....too fast if anything. I don't wear glasses and don't need them, but the action was so fast it seemed blurred.
I thought the Obi-Wan/Grevious fight was rushed, especially with how fast Obi-Wan cut off 2 of his 4 hands. I mean, Grevious is supposed to be this all powerful Jedi killing machine (no pun intended). He has numberous lightsabers from the Jedi he killed, yet in less than 3 minutes Obi-Wan has cut his attack and defense potential in half?!?!!?!
I love Ian McDiramid, I think he has done a great job with Palpatine over the years..but his lightsaber skills SUCKED!!!
R2...man, how could Lucas make me hate R2? Dunno, but he did.
There were screen shots leaked of Qui-Gon in ghost form, yet we never see him. I believe it's even on the credits too.
Mickey Suttle...aka Supershadow. Well, I initially defended him, but I've done a lot of research since then and there are huge holes in things he said. FRAUD!!!
I half thought we'd hear Vader cry out "I am not a machine, I am a human Being!" ala the Elephant Man. The manorisms were all wrong for that scene.
It takes 18 years to complete the first Death Star..when the Incrastructure and skeleton appeared to be in place at the end of EP3..yet only 6 for DS2 to be say 60% complete and have the weapons systems operational?
How about this goof. Bail Organa goes to the senate towards the end because he is the senator from? Alderan, right? Why is he in the Naboo Senate Pod?
There's more but after seeing this tradegy twice in the span of 4 hours tonight, I am off to bed..I'm so depressed...more tomorrow.
